How to Evaluate a Shopify Plus Agency: What to Look for Beyond the Partner Badge

Blog - How to Evaluate a Shopify Plus Agency
by: Avex Designs11/16/2026

Quick Summary Most Shopify Plus agency finalists can show strong work, so the badge and the portfolio won't decide it. Check what the partner tier actually measures (it changes on January 1, 2027), who will do the work, how the agency scopes, and how it will run the store after launch. The relationship you're choosing usually lasts far longer than the first project.


If you run ecommerce at a Shopify Plus brand, you will probably pick an agency more than once. A replatform, a redesign, a B2B launch, or simply a team to keep the store moving.

By the final round, most agencies look alike on paper. They all have a partner badge, logos you recognize and a case study close to your category. Those things matter, but they rarely tell you which agency will be the better partner two years from now. This guide covers what to check instead.

Start with what you need the agency for

Before you look at a single proposal, decide what kind of engagement you're buying:

  • A defined project. A migration, a redesign or a B2B launch, with a start and an end.

  • An ongoing team. Engineering, design, CRO, retention and SEO working from one roadmap, month after month.

  • A diagnosis first. You know the store isn't performing, but you don't yet know whether the answer is optimization, a phased plan or a rebuild.

Most growing brands need all three at some point. The project gets most of the attention when you're choosing, but the ongoing work is where a store keeps improving. Pick an agency that's strong at the stage you're in, and ask honestly whether you'd want them for the next one.

Understand what the partner tier means, and what it doesn't

Shopify ranks service partners in tiers, and agencies feature them prominently. It's worth knowing what they measure, especially now.

On January 1, 2027, Shopify is replacing the current Select, Plus, Premier and Platinum tiers with four new ones: Silver, Gold, Platinum and Diamond. Each new tier requires two things: a minimum attributed GMV and a minimum number of attributed shops.

  • Silver: $25K attributed GMV, 1 attributed shop, measured over 1 year

  • Gold: $5M, 5 shops, 4 years

  • Platinum: $50M, 20 shops, 4 years

  • Diamond: $500M, 25 shops, 4 years

A shop counts when the partner launched it or transferred it to the merchant. Referrals and collaborator access on their own don't count. Shopify is also retiring the "Plus Partner" name partly because merchants assumed it meant a Shopify Plus specialist, which it never did.

What this tells you:

  • A tier is evidence of launches and volume. It shows an agency has put stores live that went on to sell.

  • It isn't a measure of quality, fit or post-launch support. Shopify doesn't grade how well the store runs a year later, how the engagement went, or whether the agency is right for your catalog, integrations or team.

  • Expect badges to move. Every partner is re-tiered under the new rules on January 1, and some will go up or down. A change in the badge in early 2027 says more about the new formula than about the agency.

Use the tier and the Shopify Partner Directory to build a shortlist. Don't use them to make the final decision.

Look for work that matches your complexity

Logos tell you who an agency has worked with. They don't tell you what it actually did. When you review case studies, look for:

  • Your kind of complexity. ERP and middleware integrations, large catalogs, B2B, multiple stores or markets, subscriptions, POS. A beautiful DTC launch doesn't prove the agency can handle your NetSuite sync.

  • What the agency owned. Strategy, design, engineering, or all three? Was it the original build or ongoing work?

  • Results with context. A number is more credible when the case study says what changed and when. Our work with

    TYR

    is an example: a focused optimization sprint on product discovery and performance instead of a rebuild, followed by 25% year-over-year revenue growth and 37% more orders in Q4 2025 compared with Q4 2024.

  • Work that still runs. Ask which clients the agency still supports. Long relationships tell you more than launch announcements.

Then call references, and ask them what went wrong and how it was handled. Every project of real size runs into problems. What matters is how the agency deals with them.

Find out who will actually do the work

The people in the pitch aren't always the people on the project. Ask directly:

  • Who leads strategy, design and engineering day to day?

  • Is the work done in-house, by a partner firm or by contractors?

  • Who owns the relationship once the project starts, and how often will you hear from them?

  • How much senior involvement is planned after the kickoff?

You should be able to meet the delivery lead and the technical lead before you sign.

Judge the scope, not the price

When proposals come in, it's tempting to compare the bottom lines. The scope is where you learn how an agency thinks.

A good scope:

  • Gives firm estimates for work that's well understood.

  • Separates the genuinely uncertain items into a clear list that's pending discovery, rather than burying them in buffers or leaving them out.

  • Spells out what is committed, what is optional and what is excluded.

  • Doesn't add features you didn't ask for.

Be cautious about a proposal that's much cheaper than the rest without explaining why. Usually it has assumed away the hard parts, such as data migration, integrations, QA or content, and you'll meet them later as change orders.

If the agencies can't agree on what the project is, you may not be ready to scope it. A paid discovery or an assessment first is often cheaper than a rebuild aimed at the wrong problem. That's what our Polaris Commerce Assessment is for: it reviews conversion, search and AI discovery, performance and retention, and returns a prioritized roadmap you can execute with any team.

Not sure what the first project should be?

Test how they think about cost and complexity

Ask each finalist how they'd keep your total cost of ownership down. Strong answers usually mention:

  • Using native Shopify features first, then established apps, and custom code only where it pays off.

  • Checking the app stack for overlap before adding more.

  • Rebuilding custom checkout logic on Shopify Functions rather than recreating every legacy rule.

  • Being honest about when 80% of a feature is enough.

An agency that proposes more custom work than you expected should be able to explain what each piece is worth. Our build vs. buy post goes deeper on that trade-off.

Ask how they'll run the store after launch

Launch is the start of the work. After it come the bugs nobody found in QA, the campaign that needs new templates, the app that breaks after an update, and the conversion work that only makes sense once real customers are on the site.

Ask every finalist:

  • What does support look like in the first 90 days?

  • Do you offer ongoing engineering, design, CRO, retention and SEO under one roadmap, or would we need other vendors?

  • How do you decide what to work on each month, and how do we see progress?

  • Who keeps the roadmap honest when priorities compete?

If the answer is "we'll hand it over," plan who will own the store from then on. For many brands the better choice is an agency that can run the roadmap after launch as one team. That's how our 360 Total Support works, with CRO and retention marketing planned alongside engineering and design.

Looking for an ongoing Shopify Plus team?

A short evaluation checklist

  1. Do we need a project, an ongoing team, or a diagnosis first?

  2. What does the agency's partner tier actually reflect, and has it been re-tiered under the 2027 rules?

  3. Do its case studies match our complexity (integrations, catalog, B2B, markets)?

  4. Which clients does it still support, and for how long?

  5. Have we met the people who will do the work?

  6. Does the scope separate committed, uncertain, optional and excluded work?

  7. If one proposal is far cheaper, what did it leave out?

  8. How will the agency keep our total cost of ownership down?

  9. What happens in the first 90 days after launch?

  10. Can the same team run engineering, design, CRO, retention and SEO from one roadmap afterwards?

How Avex approaches it

We're a Shopify Platinum agency based in New York, working with mid-market and enterprise brands on strategy, design and engineering. Most of our relationships start with a defined piece of work, often a Polaris Commerce Assessment or a design and build project, and continue as an ongoing team through 360 Total Support.

FAQ

What is a Shopify Plus agency?

An agency that designs, builds and supports stores on Shopify Plus, Shopify's plan for larger brands. Shopify doesn't certify "Plus agencies" separately. Look at the agency's partner tier and its published Plus work.

What do the Shopify partner tiers mean?

From January 1, 2027, Shopify's service partner tiers are Silver, Gold, Platinum and Diamond. Each requires a minimum attributed GMV and number of attributed shops, from $25K and one shop for Silver up to $500M and 25 shops for Diamond.

Is a Shopify Plus Partner the same as a Shopify Plus agency?

No. "Plus" was a partner tier name, not a Shopify Plus specialization. Shopify is retiring it on January 1, 2027, partly because of that confusion.

What questions should I ask a Shopify Plus agency?

Ask who will do the work, which comparable projects they've delivered, which clients they still support, how they separate firm and uncertain scope, how they'll control total cost of ownership, and what support looks like after launch.

Should I hire one agency for the build and another for ongoing support?

It can work, but every handover loses context. If the build agency can also run engineering, design, CRO and retention afterwards, one team usually keeps the roadmap more coherent.

Should I get an assessment before choosing an agency for a rebuild?

If you aren't sure whether the store needs optimization, a phased plan or a rebuild, yes. A diagnosis first keeps you from scoping the wrong project.

If you're evaluating agencies for your next stage on Shopify Plus, let's talk.

Let's discuss your ecommerce goals

Schedule a consultation call with one of our experts.

CONTACT US
Let's discuss your ecommerce goals